I like "Shame on the Moon" well enough, although it takes a while to become interesting. The verses plod a bit and the only part I really like is the two-line chorus. "Against the Wind" on the other hand has an emotional power that "Shame on the Moon" doesn't. It has that drama that I love in a song. For me, "Against the Wind" is beautiful and moving and "Shame on the Moon" is just alright.

Of course it's all subjective - those are just my impressions.