There are a couple of songs by the band that I find laugh out loud terrible("Nightingale" and "Love Will Keep Us Alive") and also a couple for which I simply do not care(studio version of "Saturday Night" and "Get Over it").
"Teenage Jail," however, is the one Eagles song I completely and unreservedly detest. I wholeheartedly vote it off the island.
And now for my defence of 'Disco Strangler': Think of it more as a Henley solo song, as opposed to an Eagles song. At that point, the song might not suffer as much from inflated expectations that come with the listening of an 'Eagles' song. Short, simple, and skeweringly to the point--Very much in the same vein as the Punk bands of that era(Captain Sensible, Clash, Ramones, Sex Pistols, etc) Lyrics aptly sum up the darkest aspects of the dance/party scene in the city. The guitars perfectly compliment those lacerating lyrics(outside the chorus, the chord for the song is one finger on one higher-pitched string towards the top of the guitar neck) Probably one of the truly unsung greats by America's best, and very much in need of a re-appraisal.