Underrated Eagles Song Survivor

[VAisForEagleLovers]

I think we are voting for the least underrated (ie the most overrated) first.

Yes, UTW, you are correct, the least underrated. The winner should be the song that is the most underrated Eagles song.

I hope no one faints that I'm playing along. The overall premise is to 'vote things off the island' and there's too much I love about the Eagles to be voting against things. However for this particular game, most of these songs either do nothing for me or I actually dislike them, so I have no problems 'voting things off'.

I am going to use the logic Soda used for LROOE, and vote for The Last Resort. The song has had too much acclaim to be considered underrated in my opinion, and given my thoughts on the song, I feel that acclaim has vastly overrated it.

[Brooke]

I know I'm confused for sure!

[Glennsallnighter]

In that case I will vote for 'The Lat Resort' as its not so terribly underrated, having been on the HFO dvd etc

[Ive always been a dreamer]

I'm just a bit confused here, sorry!! ,

Are we voting off the underrated songs in order of the MOST underrated song being voted off first, the Least underrated song being voted off first (in ones opinion) or just putting them all on equal footing and voting the, off based on our own preferences as to how well we like them as songs.

Even though others have answered this correctly, I feel I should give an "official' answer. The surviving song and winner of the game should be the song that the players feel is the MOST underrated Eagles song. Therefore, in each round until the final round, you should vote for the song that you feel is the least deserving of that title. Hope that makes sense to everyone. If not, speak up, and, hopefully, we can clear up any other misunderstandings.

[zeldabjr]

I vote for Pretty Maids All in a Row...

[UK TimFan]

I vote for 'Pretty maids all in a row'.

[Ive always been a dreamer]

I cast my vote for Most of Us Are Sad.

The way I think about this is that in order for me to consider a song underrated, I have to think it is a really good song that doesn't get the props it deserves. Since MOUAS is one of the weaker songs in the band's catalog, I can't say it's underrated.

[Ive always been a dreamer]

The first song performance to be eliminated in the Underrated Eagles Song Survivor is Most of Us Are Sad. “Most of Us Are Sad”, no one can save you now. The tribe has spoken. We will sing you far away because you must leave the island immediately.

Votes
Most of Us Are Sad – 4
James Dean – 3
The Last Resort – 3
Ol' 55 – 2
Pretty Maids All in a Row – 2
Long Road Out of Eden – 1
Bitter Creek – 1
The Sad Café – 1
Doolin-Dalton/Desperado Reprise – 1

Vote Breakdown
Most of Us Are Sad – Freypower
Most of Us Are Sad – GlennLover
Most of Us Are Sad – Brooke
Most of Us Are Sad – Ive always been a dreamer
James Dean – Lacken101
James Dean – thelastresort
James Dean – Desperada
The Last Resort – UndertheWire
The Last Resort – VAisForEagleLovers
The Last Resort – Glennsallnighter
Ol' 55 – DevineDon
Ol' 55 – scottside
Pretty Maids All in a Row – zeldabjr
Pretty Maids All in a Row – UK TimFan
Long Road Out of Eden – sodascouts
Bitter Creek – WalshFan88
The Sad Café – NightMistBlue
Doolin-Dalton/Desperado Reprise – Midnight Visitor

Songs eliminated:
Most of Us Are Sad 1/29

Songs remaining:
Bitter Creek
Doolin-Dalton/Desperado Reprise
James Dean
Ol' 55
Good Day in Hell
My Man
After the Thrill Is Gone
Too Many Hands
Pretty Maids All in a Row
The Last Resort
Those Shoes
The Sad Cafe
Long Road Out of Eden
Do Something


Voting for Round Two begins now.

[LA Eagle]

James Dean

[Freypower]

The Last Resort. It featured prominently in HFO & it's widely praised. I don't believe it's underrated at all.