Didn’t Peter Gabriel leave Genesis more than 40 years ago? I believe there are a significant number of Genesis fans who identify the band with Phil Collins and not Peter Gabriel so much. I may be wrong but Genesis probably sold a whole lot more albums when Collins was the lead singer. To me, it would seem odd or even pointless for Genesis to reunite with Gabriel as the only original member. It’s a completely different scenario from the Eagles continuing on with Henley as the only original member. Don was always part of the band while it was a functioning entity and was an integral part of the Eagles’ biggest-selling albums.
Back to the poll, I’m surprised there aren’t more votes. Maybe I should have included an option “don’t care.”
I also figured there would be a couple of “no” votes due to doubts on how influential Henley’s music has been.