To me, I still consider footage around live performances of a song and surrounding activity to be a music video. Even if it's not the most creative way to make it, I don't mind as long as it's interesting to me. As far as I'm concerned, it takes just as much creativity to shoot that kind of video than it does to stick a dude on a conveyor belt and just film him singing. As I said before, that doesn't do anything for me at all. But, even if I thought all things were equal about the videos (which I don't), then my tiebreaker would be which song I like the best. And that's easy for me too - One Day at a Time is about a hundred times better song than The Radio Song, IMO. Since the round is tied with my vote, I hope I can convince others to join me in this round ...

I cast my vote for The Radio Song.