I'm exasperated with myself for not being able to find the words to explain! It is very subjective. I personally always listen to the tune of the song first - the melody, music and the beat - before I listen to the lyrics. I don't know why it's like that for me. I used to be a lyrics girl (back when they put the lyrics on the album cover - LOVED that), but now it can be years before I pay attention to the lyrics of a song. I wish it were different for me, but that's how it is.
Visions appeals to me in all the categories I first mentioned. I like the sound of the song. I don't LOVE it...I don't really LOVE hardly any of these songs.
When I play Survivor, I try to treat the songs as if I'm hearing them all for the first time. Then I make my list. I try not to overthink it, but when we start talking about them like this sometimes I second guess myself.