Ah - spoken like a true contrarian, F50. There is a difference between speculation and known facts. It's okay to speculate about things based on known facts. It is not okay to misrepresent speculation as facts. In addition, it crosses the line when speculating on situations without knowing or disregarding the facts or making inflammatory and judgmental comments. As I said in another thread recently, if you find the distinction is murky and you're unsure where to draw the line, then it is better to err on the side of caution and not comment at all. Here's how this is addressed in our Netiquette Guidelines
6. Stick to facts when discussing a topic. As we said earlier, we want to encourage discussion - after all, that's what the board is all about. There are times when a topic is pure rumor, speculation, or opinion, and that is fine. However, you want to be clear so that you do not misrepresent rumor, speculation, or opinion as fact. Regarding the more scandalous, unsavory, unsubstantiated gossip: it doesn't need to be on the board at all.
If you have any other questions about this, please feel free to PM me or one of the other moderators, and we'll be glad to try to clarify this for you.