Originally Posted by Shadowland07
The Eagles have no better song than Hotel Caliornia. Yes, Felder does deserve to be an equal & not only because of HC, but as a member of the band...Why is one band member more important than another? That only happens in Eagleland.... Other bands don't operate that way.So because of 1 song Felder should have been an equal!? Hahaha yeah right. "Hotel California" is an overrated song, the Eagles have better songs than it. Oh yeah, they do have other songs.
HC is THE DEFINING SONG of the Eagles & they would not be where they are today without it. NO WAY...
As a member of the band yes of course he is an equal.
My personal fave is Take It to the Limit.
You can play the "What If" game all you want, but one thing is certain: the Eagles could not continue with the tensions between Frey and Felder, and therefore, the exit of Felder in 2001 was necessary for the continuance of the band. If it's between the Eagles without Felder and no Eagles at all, I'll take the former choice.
Those are great songs indeed. But to compare, Hotel California is to Queen's Bohemian Rhapsody what Lyin Eyes is to Queens crazy little thing called love.
HC and BR are Top Shelf Rock Classic MASTERPIECE....thats the word I was looking for Hotel California is a MASTERPIECE, which is different than being a Great Song like the other ones.
I'm just going to apologize for starting another argument. I didnt mean to. I'm sorry we all have our opinions but maybe I should've kept mine to myself as to not stir up feelings again, so sorry.