You guys have reminded me of a lot of ones that I agree with!

Soda, I completely forgot about Celine Dion! "Because You Loved Me" makes me cry every single time, but the song that REALLY makes me absolutely bawl of hers is "Goodbye's The Saddest Word."

Some other ones that you all mentioned that I had forgotten:

When I Get Where I'm Going - Brad Paisley/Dolly Parton
One - U2
Where The Streets Have No Name - U2 (superbowl performance)
Hurt - Johnny Cash
Tears In Heaven - Eric Clapton
Christmas Shoes - Newsong
Arise My Love - Newsong

And Willie, I was the same way with How Long