Joe Walsh Greatest Hits Survivor!

[sodascouts]

ITA with both of you. I can't believe Turn to Stone is gone!

I cast my vote All Night Long.

[ticky]

this is gettin ugly now. I have listened and relistened and it came down to Life's been good, and All night long. I reeealy like All Night Long.. but Life's been good is better! its better guitar work, its better written (more well written? ) its just a better song.. ok.. so.. PAINFULLY (anguish anguish..) I vote for All Night Long

[Wildthyme]

I am with all of you and I cast my vote for All Night Long. Time for it to leave the island...

[TimothyBFan]

I really enjoy the get up and move stuff of Joes and most of them all became the BIG hits. Those have always been the ones I like the most.

That being said, at the risk of making some of you very mad at me, I will have to vote for Help Me Thru The Night. I'm really sorry--I don't want any of these to go. Why does this game feel so wrong?

[Prettymaid]

I really enjoy the get up and move stuff of Joes and most of them all became the BIG hits. Those have always been the ones I like the most.

That being said, at the risk of making some of you very mad at me, I will have to vote for Help Me Thru The Night. I'm really sorry--I don't want any of these to go. Why does this game feel so wrong?

I'm not mad at you TBF. It is getting down to the nitty gritty, and we all have our favorites. That's what makes this game so fun!

[TimothyBFan]

I'm not mad at you TBF. It is getting down to the nitty gritty, and we all have our favorites. That's what makes this game so fun!

Glad you're not mad. But "fun"-are you crazy? This is torture! I liked the way Ticky put it earlier in the game-"like killing puppies" or such. Maybe not quite that drastic but feels like getting rid of old friends doesn't it.

[Prettymaid]

Glad you're not mad. But "fun"-are you crazy? This is torture! I liked the way Ticky put it earlier in the game-"like killing puppies" or such. Maybe not quite that drastic but feels like getting rid of old friends doesn't it.

I guess I don't think of it that way. It's not like we're banning the songs from ever being listened to again! It's a game. I'm enjoying reading everyone's views

BTW, I liked Ticky's "like killing puppies" comparison, too.

[sodascouts]

Aw, don't feel too bad about eliminating songs! It's all in good fun, and I think it's fairly obvious that we all appreciate Joe's catalog here. It's just very interesting to see people's comments on the songs and how they affect us in different ways - plus, I'm curious as to what will win!

And TBF - I'm certainly not mad at you for voting for HMTTN... not at all....



Oops, accidentally shot off my nuclear flame thrower. Hope I didn't hit you.

[glenneaglesfan]

Lol, Soda!!

I can't believe Turn To Stone has gone. It's one of the only Eagles related songs I ever get to hear in hubby's car as it's on a compilation. It looks as if All Night Long might go out this round, so reluctantly I'm going to vote for Funk#49.

[Brooke]

I cast my vote for Walk Away.